Brandon Hurst’s Chick-fil-A Restaurants Outpace Systemwide Sales Benchmarks

| 5 min read

Brandon J. Hurst’s two Chick-fil-A restaurants in Brooklyn reportedly generate sales well above the chain’s published benchmarks. His account points to a business built around dense urban locations, experienced teams and an operating structure designed to reduce reliance on the owner.

Hurst opened his first restaurant in Brooklyn across from Barclays Center in 2019, then added a Clinton Hill location in November 2024. He says both are among the chain’s highest-grossing restaurants, though he hasn’t disclosed their sales. For context, Restaurant Business reported that stand-alone Chick-fil-A restaurants averaged nearly $9.2 million in sales in 2025. The chain’s busiest location exceeded $20 million, while its top-performing mall restaurant recorded $14.4 million.

“Well north of those numbers,” Hurst said when asked how his restaurants compare. That claim is unquantified, so it doesn’t reveal how far his locations exceed those reference points. Still, the operating profile is notable: urban restaurants without the large suburban drive-through format can draw on dense neighborhoods and event traffic, including crowds around Barclays Center.

From a $12-an-hour job to restaurant operator

Hurst entered the restaurant business after graduating from Alabama State University in 2010. He considered pursuing a master’s degree in accounting or applying to law school before accepting a $12-an-hour job at a Chick-fil-A in Chicago. Two weeks after graduation, he packed his belongings and drove from Alabama to begin work there.

The role offered direct exposure to restaurant operations and a path toward leadership. Hurst wanted a career with an entrepreneurial dimension, but he says he was more interested in operational strategy and developing leaders than creating a restaurant concept from scratch. Chick-fil-A already had a known brand, menu and operating system, which let him focus on running teams and stores.

In 2012, he joined the company’s leadership development program. Over the next three years, he helped 14 operators launch restaurants around the country. Twelve of those operators were external candidates who had never owned or worked at a Chick-fil-A. The repeated openings gave Hurst practice in preparing teams and launching locations before he took charge of a restaurant himself.

He opened his first location in downtown Baltimore in April 2015, at age 26. The restaurant gave Chick-fil-A a chance to learn how its model could work in a dense urban setting, where customers couldn’t be served primarily through a large drive-through. Hurst spent five years in Baltimore before handing the location to other operators and moving to Brooklyn.

A lower entry fee comes with a different ownership model

Chick-fil-A’s operator program has a distinctive financial structure. The initial franchise fee is $10,000, a figure that has remained unchanged for 50 years, according to The New York Post. Applicants must use their own funds to pay it; borrowed or gifted money isn’t accepted.

That relatively small fee doesn’t buy a restaurant or its assets. Chick-fil-A selects operators to run locations that the company finances, including major startup costs such as construction and equipment. Operators manage the business but don’t acquire an asset they can later sell or pass on to heirs.

That setup differs from the more common franchise arrangement, in which an operator funds much of the startup investment and owns the business that uses the franchisor’s brand. The ADP estimate puts many franchise startup costs between $100,000 and $300,000, with restaurants and hotels often at the higher end.

Access to Chick-fil-A’s model is highly competitive. About 100,000 people apply annually to become operators, and roughly 200 are selected, according to The New York Post. Selected operators must work full time in the business and divest other non-passive business interests. Chick-fil-A describes the role as active operation, not passive investment, on its franchise information page.

Operators receive a share of restaurant profits rather than a conventional corporate salary. Reported annual take-home income typically ranges from $200,000 to $400,000, with top performers earning more than $500,000. Those figures come with an important trade-off: operators can earn from a successful location, but they don’t build equity in the restaurant itself.

Retention is part of Hurst’s operating strategy

Hurst credits his employees as a major factor in the Brooklyn restaurants’ performance. His approach includes housing support, health services and education benefits—costs that reflect a deliberate effort to keep staff in a demanding, high-volume business.

He purchased a multifamily building in Brooklyn where team members can rent at below-market rates. Employees also have access to free mental health care, including up to 10 therapy sessions, and telehealth services that cover their households. Eligible college students can receive reimbursement for textbooks.

Hurst says his leaders stay an average of about four years. Among regular team members, he considers retention beyond 12 to 16 months a win. Those timelines suggest that continuity is concentrated among leaders, while front-line roles remain harder to retain for extended periods.

His hiring conversations focus on how candidates respond to pressure and what support would help them thrive. He asks applicants to describe a time they wanted to give up and why they kept going. Another question—how they define care for themselves—helps him understand what meaningful support might look like for each person.

Providing support is only one part of building a business that can grow. Hurst says he’s also working to make sure major decisions, relationships and problems don’t all depend on him. If the owner remains the required route for every important issue, he argues, the organization hasn’t developed enough leadership capacity to scale.

Building an organization that can operate beyond its founder

About five years ago, Hurst hired an executive assistant to organize his calendar and free up time for other work. That shift helped him make room for writing, including his book Outthink Yourself, scheduled for release in January. He describes it as a four-year project for readers navigating growth, whether they’re leading a team for the first time or building a business.

Hurst frames his approach to growth in three stages: see, become and build. First, assess the opportunity, problem or risk. Then develop the skills needed to respond. Finally, put systems in place so progress can continue over time. He sees the same sequence in his own path: taking a chance on Chicago, learning to lead through the restaurant launch program, and building teams to support multiple locations.

His next goals include expanding his Chick-fil-A portfolio and working with entrepreneurs through speaking and training workshops. He has also started developing a second book focused on applying his ideas. The practical test for Hurst’s business will be whether strong sales and employee support can continue as the organization adds locations without routing every decision through him.

Source: Sherin Shibu · www.entrepreneur.com