Kosterina’s First 100 Customers Show How Early Demand Can Grow Without Ads
Kosterina’s early traction came from customer behavior that paid advertising can’t guarantee: repeat purchases, referrals and interest from shoppers outside founder Katina Mountanos’ personal network. The company reached its first 50 to 100 customers without paid ads, then used feedback and organic discovery to test whether demand could extend beyond friends and family.
Mountanos started the extra virgin olive oil and wellness brand as a side project while working full-time at Walmart. At roughly 100 customers, a Net Promoter Score survey returned a score of 100. Whole Foods later contacted Kosterina after finding the brand on Instagram. The company now sells through Target, HEB, Crate & Barrel and other national retailers.
That path offers a practical early-stage business lesson: a small customer base can provide useful evidence before a founder commits heavily to marketing or leaves a stable job. The evidence is strongest when buyers return, recommend the product and begin arriving without a personal connection to the founder.
Early sales are a starting point, not proof
Friends and family can be a sensible first customer group. They’re accessible, can try an early version of the product, and can provide direct feedback without the cost of a paid acquisition campaign. But their first purchase alone says little about demand. Personal support may explain the sale, so founders need to watch what follows.
For Kosterina, the more informative signals were repeat orders and referrals. A customer who buys again has shown a willingness to spend beyond an initial act of encouragement. A customer who introduces the product to someone else is putting their own reputation behind it. And when orders come from people the founder doesn’t know, the business has begun to reach beyond its original network.
Those signals help separate early enthusiasm from a pattern that might support growth. They don’t guarantee that a company can scale profitably: a founder still needs to understand costs, fulfillment and customer retention. But they offer a more useful read on product demand than a tally of first-time purchases alone.
Use customer feedback to test the proposition
When Kosterina had about 100 customers, Mountanos sent a Net Promoter Score survey asking how likely each person was to recommend the product to a friend. The score ranges from -100 to 100, and Kosterina received 100. Mountanos had worked with NPS across brands at Walmart, so she recognized the result as an unusually strong endorsement from the respondents.
A score that high can be encouraging, but it’s a signal from a particular group of customers, not a complete measure of a business. For a young company, a short survey can still help reveal whether the product is resonating and where customers see room for improvement. Responses become more useful when founders pair them with observed behavior: who reorders, who refers, and whether new buyers arrive without prompting.
The approach is inexpensive. A founder can ask early buyers directly, then compare what they say with what they do. That makes customer research part of operating the business rather than a separate, costly project.
Put limited resources into the experience
Kosterina’s early marketing rested on the product, packaging, sampling and education. The company focused on high-quality olive oil and packaging designed to stand out. Those choices gave customers something to use, discuss and give as a gift, while sampling let prospective buyers experience the product directly.
Sampling can be especially useful when a product’s appeal is easier to understand through use than through an advertisement. Kosterina also treated gifting as a route to discovery: people who received a bottle could become customers themselves. The method depends on having a product that delivers after the first try, since exposure alone won’t create repeat business.
Education gave the brand another way to earn attention. Many shoppers may not know how olive oil quality differs or what high-polyphenol extra virgin olive oil means. Content about olive oil, the Mediterranean diet, recipes and wellness gave Kosterina a way to explain its product and build interest beyond a direct sales pitch.
That work can extend a small budget, but it still takes time and a clear point of view. The useful test is whether the information helps customers understand the product and decide whether it suits them, rather than simply filling a publishing schedule.
Let discovery create options, while keeping plans flexible
Kosterina’s packaging and presence on Instagram helped it attract Whole Foods’ attention. The retailer reached out after discovering the brand online, creating an opportunity the company hadn’t bought through advertising. That kind of inbound interest is valuable, though a retail opening brings its own demands and doesn’t by itself establish long-term economics.
The company’s initial Whole Foods launch plan relied on in-store sampling. When COVID prevented sampling in stores for more than a year, the team had to find other ways to reach consumers. The episode shows why a customer acquisition plan should have alternatives: a channel that works today can become unavailable, and a young business needs other ways to introduce its product.
Build evidence before making a larger commitment
Mountanos developed Kosterina while keeping her full-time Walmart role. That gave her time to refine the product and observe customer demand before making the brand her primary focus. Repeat purchases, referrals, the NPS result and Whole Foods’ outreach contributed to the case that the business had potential beyond a personal project.
For founders with limited resources, the sequence matters. Get a product into customers’ hands, learn from their feedback and track the behavior that follows. Spend effort on quality, presentation and useful education, then look for signs that demand can travel beyond the people already inclined to support you.
Kosterina’s experience doesn’t establish a formula for every business, and a strong early response won’t answer every question about future growth. It does show how founders can use a small initial customer base to test a product before making larger commitments. The next milestone is not simply reaching 100 buyers; it’s seeing whether enough of them return, recommend the product and bring new customers with them.